You Know What to Do. So Why Aren't You Doing It?

    Because most of what you do isn't decided by the part of you that knows better. Here is the science of the autopilot, and how to train it.

    By Hanna Horner · Published · Updated · 7 min read

    THE SHORT ANSWER

    Knowing what to do lives in your conscious mind, but most daily behaviour runs on habits and gut-level feelings that bypass conscious motivation. Automatic attitudes toward exercise predict how active people are, if-then plans make the right response automatic, and an identity shift keeps people training months later. The fix is training the autopilot, not more information.

    You don't have an information problem.

    You have read the books. You know about protein. You know you should lift. You know alcohol wrecks your sleep. You could teach a class on it.

    And you are still not doing it consistently.

    That is not a character flaw. It is how brains work. And once you see it, you can stop blaming yourself and start fixing the right thing.

    Most of what you do isn't decided by the part of you that knows better.

    Habits are actions your brain fires automatically when it sees a familiar cue. They bypass conscious motivation completely. That is the point of them: they keep going when motivation is gone (Gardner and Lally, 2018).

    So the part of you that KNOWS is not the part that DECIDES at 6 pm on a Tuesday.

    Your gut-level feelings run the show.

    Researchers measure something called implicit attitudes: your instant, automatic feeling about something, before you have time to think.

    Across 26 studies, people's automatic feelings about exercise were linked to how active they actually were (Chevance et al., 2019). In one study, those automatic feelings predicted how many steps people took in a week, even after accounting for their intentions and their confidence (Conroy et al., 2010).

    Read that again. What you intend matters less than what you automatically FEEL.

    Three tools that work at the automatic level.

    1. If-then plans. "If it's 6 am, then shoes on." Across 94 tests, these simple plans had a medium-to-large effect on reaching goals. Part of why: they make the response automatic, so you skip the negotiation (Gollwitzer and Sheeran, 2006).

    2. Identity before action. In a trial with 276 inactive women, 16 weeks of training raised their sense of being "someone who exercises." The bigger that shift, the more they exercised six months later, on their own (Gillman et al., 2021). I always become before I do. Now you know why that works.

    Your beliefs work the same way. Read what you believe about aging changes how long you live.

    3. Repetition in the same context. Habits form through repetition with the same cue, and the time it takes varies a LOT from person to person. I wrote about that in how to make habits stick.

    Where hypnosis comes in.

    Habits, automatic feelings and identity all live below conscious thought. That is exactly the level hypnosis is built to work on.

    It is not willpower. It is not another plan. It is getting the autopilot on your side, so the right choice is the easy one. In my clinical practice, that is where women stop starting and stopping.

    My head is never quiet. It is singing three songs it doesn't know the lyrics to and remembering the right things at the wrong times. And I still do the things. Not because I'm disciplined. Because I trained the part of me that does them automatically.

    Sources. Gardner B, Lally P. Modelling habit formation and its determinants. In: The Psychology of Habit. Springer. 2018. Chevance G, et al. The association between implicit attitudes toward physical activity and physical activity behaviour. Health Psychol Rev. 2019. Conroy DE, et al. Implicit attitudes and explicit motivation prospectively predict physical activity. Ann Behav Med. 2010. Gollwitzer PM, Sheeran P. Implementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis. Adv Exp Soc Psychol. 2006. Gillman AS, Stevens CJ, Bryan AD. Women's exercise identity increases after a 16-week exercise RCT and is linked to behavior maintenance at follow-up. Psychol Sport Exerc. 2021.

    Related posts