Insulin Resistant? Why Protein Is the Smartest Swap for Your Carbs
Fewer carbs means those calories have to come from somewhere. The research says protein is the place: it burns more to digest, keeps you fuller and protects your muscle.
By Hanna Horner · Published · Updated · 6 min read
THE SHORT ANSWER
If insulin resistance means you can't eat the carbs you used to, protein is the smartest place for those calories. It is the most thermogenic macronutrient, higher-protein diets raise energy expenditure, and swapping carbs for protein at the same calories helps you lose more fat and keep more muscle. The right carb level depends on how insulin resistant you are, which is why your macros should not be your friend's macros.
Insulin resistant means fewer carbs. Fine. 🤷♀️
But those calories have to come from SOMEWHERE. And where they go decides whether you lose fat or lose muscle.
My answer is protein. Here is why the research agrees.
Protein burns more just to digest it.
Your body spends energy processing food. It is called diet-induced thermogenesis, and protein costs the most of any macronutrient except alcohol. That extra burn is also a big part of why protein keeps you full (Westerterp, 2004).
A 2024 analysis of 52 studies found that higher-protein meals raised the calories burned after eating and across the day. In diets lasting from four days to a year, higher protein raised both total and resting energy expenditure (Guarneiri et al., 2024).
Carbs you can't handle well, swapped for protein that costs more to process. That is not a diet trick. That is physiology.
Swap carbs for protein and you keep your muscle.
Across 24 randomized trials, researchers compared diets with the same calories and the same fat, where the only difference was more protein and fewer carbs. The higher-protein versions lost more fat, lost less lean mass and protected resting metabolism better (Wycherley et al., 2012).
Same plate size. Different ratio. Better body.
Your insulin status changes the right ratio.
This is the part nobody tells you. How your body handles carbs depends on how insulin resistant you are.
- After weight loss, people on a 20% carb diet burned about 209 calories a day more than people on a 60% carb diet. In people with the highest insulin output, the gap was 308 to 478 calories a day (Ebbeling et al., 2018). That result has been debated by other researchers (Hall et al., 2019), so treat the exact number with care.
- Women with low insulin sensitivity lost 4.9 kg of fat on a low-carb diet, versus 2.1 kg on low-fat (Martins et al., 2025).
- With the same 10% weight loss, a very-low-carb diet improved liver insulin sensitivity two to three times more than Mediterranean or very-low-fat diets in people with prediabetes and fatty liver (Petersen et al., 2026).
And the flip side: insulin-sensitive women in another trial lost more on a lower-fat diet (Rock et al., 2016).
So no, there is no one magic ratio. There is YOUR ratio.
What that means in PRYME.
Your carbs are matched to your metabolism, and protein carries more of the load when insulin resistance is in the picture. That is why the perimenopause path runs higher protein by default, and why your macros are not your friend's macros.
If you notice the same meal hitting harder than it used to, read why blood sugar spikes harder in perimenopause. For the protein number itself, read 1 gram per pound of goal weight: too much in perimenopause?
Crunchy, clean, unprocessed. Protein first. Carbs that earn their place.
Sources. Westerterp KR. Diet induced thermogenesis. Nutr Metab. 2004. Guarneiri LL, et al. Effects of varying protein amounts and types on diet-induced thermogenesis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Adv Nutr. 2024. Wycherley TP, et al. Effects of energy-restricted high-protein, low-fat compared with standard-protein, low-fat diets. Am J Clin Nutr. 2012. Ebbeling CB, et al. Effects of a low carbohydrate diet on energy expenditure during weight loss maintenance. BMJ. 2018. Hall KD, et al. Do low-carbohydrate diets increase energy expenditure? Int J Obes. 2019. Martins C, et al. The impact of a low-carbohydrate vs low-fat diet on fat mass loss is modulated by insulin sensitivity. Obesity. 2025. Petersen MC, et al. Effect of diet macronutrient content on the cardiometabolic response to weight loss. Cell Metab. 2026. Rock CL, et al. Effects of diet composition on weight loss by baseline insulin resistance status. Metabolism. 2016.